| Platinum | Pancho Villa's Mexican & Seafood Restaurant |
| Gold | The Porch Kitchen and Cantina |
| Silver | Mi Pueblo Mexican Grill |
| Bronze | Mi Pueblo Stratford |
| Top Pick | Don Zapata's Mexican Grill |
| Top Pick | LA Botana Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | LA Carreta Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Playa Azul |
| Top Pick | Senor Bravo's |
| Top Pick | Xcaret Mexican Grill & Cantina |