| Platinum | Chill Nitro Creamery |
| Gold | Natabelles Desserts |
| Silver | Jason's Deli |
| Bronze | Midtown Cafe & Dessertery |
| Top Pick | Cafe Gelato |
| Top Pick | Dewey's Bakery |
| Top Pick | Kilwins |
| Top Pick | Klim's Caramels |
| Top Pick | Oh My Cookies |
| Top Pick | Wilkerson Moravian Bakery |