| Platinum | Vincenzo's Italian Restaurant |
| Gold | Di Lisio's Italian Restaurant |
| Silver | Elizabeth's Italian Restaurant |
| Silver | Vinnie's Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant |
| Bronze | Blue Naples Pizza |
| Top Pick | Cibo Trattoria |
| Top Pick | Cugino Forno Pizzeria Winston Salem |
| Top Pick | Mama Mia Italian Pizzaria |