| Platinum | Mellow Mushroom Winston-Salem |
| Gold | Brothers Pizzeria |
| Silver | Burke Street Pizza |
| Bronze | Elizabeth's Pizza Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Cicis Pizza |
| Top Pick | Little Italy Pizza & Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Mama Mia Italian Pizzaria |
| Top Pick | Mario's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Vincenzo's Pizza Delivery |
| Top Pick | Zito Pizzeria and Grill |
| Cugino Forno Pizzeria Winston Salem |